Back to the blog

Blog

DOJ Changed Its Position on Young Adults and Handguns. The Courts Still Matter.

By Community
Two empty voting booths bearing American flags and the word 'Vote' in front of blue dividers.

Reporting current as of October 11, 2026.

For an otherwise eligible 19-year-old looking at a dealer’s handgun case, the Justice Department’s September 18 announcement concerns whether a federal sale restriction can be criminally enforced. DOJ announced that it cannot, following a September 17 Office of Legal Counsel opinion; the administration’s lawyers have changed their legal position on that transaction.

DOJ’s explanation treats 18-to-20-year-olds as members of the political community protected by the Second Amendment and argues that restricting acquisition lacks a sufficient historical analogue. It points to civic and criminal responsibilities adults already bear, making age a question about how the government justifies excluding people it otherwise treats as adults.

The full OLC opinion acknowledges contrary judicial decisions and explains why its authors believe later Supreme Court rulings undermine them. That is an argument courts can assess, it does not repeal the statutes or resolve every state’s separate restrictions.

The opinion’s discussion of alternative channels also challenges the claim that gifts or private transfers make a dealer restriction inconsequential. A route that depends on another willing person or a secondary market is not equally available to everyone, which gives the access argument a practical consequence beyond comparing birthdays.

The scope of DOJ’s announcement remains particular federal dealer restrictions and criminal enforcement concerning otherwise eligible young adults. Treating those adults seriously means stating that scope plainly: the executive branch’s new position changes the enforcement question, while applicable state rules and separate carry restrictions still need their own answers.

Illustrative stock photo. Photo by Jesse Paul on Unsplash — Photo source.